Is my offer fair? [WHIR]

[DCFan17]

Hey folks... I have a pretty solid team. I'm actually happy about every position, except QB.

Call me crazy, I know... but I have Roethlisberger and I am never comfortable... just personal preference.

I like Romo this season, and the guy has Vick already too...
He has Tony Romo, Michael Vick and Greg Olsen.
I have Ben Roethlisberger, Tony Gonzales and Jermichael Finely.

Would this be a fair trade?

Should I offer Ben Roethlisberger and Tony Gonzales for Tony Romo?
Or how about I offer Ben Roethlisberger, Tony Gonzales and Steve Johnson for Tony Romo and DeSean Jackson?

Which is better... or which is more fair?
I'm not worried about my TE as I have Jermichael Finely.

[sylence2k2]

I think the 1st offer is more than fair, as long as you have a better TE option than Gonzo. I'm pretty sure both Romo and Rothelsburg are projected around the same total points this year...

gl

help?

viewtopic.php?t=493096

[DCFan17]

I added more info while you were replying, apologies.

[FantasyLegend]

First trade would be more fair unless he'll accept the second trade. Desean Jackson would be a steal if you got him. But personally, I don't think Romo will have a better season than Roethlisberger. You can even look at the Free Agents for a better QB or a good backup. I have Stafford as my starter going into the season. If he's available in your league, grab him. He will break out this year. I guarantee it.

Rate my team? viewtopic.php?t=493077

[zephyr]

I think the first offer is solid. I agree Romo should be the better QB this year and Tony G has fallen down towards the middle of the pack at TE. Now, if you can get the 2nd offer accepted, I prefer that one. I think Johnson is in line for a potential letdown and Jackson would definitely be the better option of the two.

Mine? viewtopic.php?t=493101