Kickers

[Wolfpac11680]

Would you rather have Neil Rackers from Houston or Janikowski from Oakland? Its standard scoring:
1-39 yards - 3 points
40-49 yards - 4 points
50-59 yards - 5 points
60-69 yards - 6 points

I like Janikowski's ability and strength over Rackers but Oaklands offense scares me.

Who would you rather have?

[sixer03fan]

This might be the first kickers question in the history of the site. They're kickers lol... Here's what you do, wait til the last round, flip a coin, and pick one.

Having said that I'd rather have Rackers. Ability shmability, you should take the one with the better offense. But predicting kickers is a total crap shoot either way.

[latsprewell20002000]

I would rather have Janikowski. Seems like Oakland just tries to get the ball on the other side of the fifty so that he can take a shot at one. Its like their entire offense it seems. But yeah just draft one with your last pick. It really does not matter.

[markulous]

I'd rather have Bryant or Brown. But if I had to choose I'd roll with Janikowski. He's got a bigger leg and is on an offense that will likely stall out in the redzone more.

[Mercury0021]

a philly kicker has been the top 5 in kicker scoring in the last 5 years, pick the rookie with the last pick and laugh at everyone.

[windchill]

My rule for kickers....wait till last round, or two, and take best indoor kicker (no wind/weather half the year or more)....so Rackers of your choices.

Mine?
viewtopic.php?t=493329