Please rate my teams

[Chaoyi Shih]

Team 1 Yahoo Auction Draft Standard 10 man League, 4pt PTD, 6pt for all other TD, non-PPR, 25yard/1pt

1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1 Def

QB: Drew Brees, Joe Flacco
RB: Maurice Jones-Drew, Beanie Wells, Ryan Grant, James Starks, LaDainian Tomlinson
WR: Andre Johnson, Greg Jennings, Mario Manningham, Reggie Wayne
TE: Dallas Clark, Greg Olsen
PK: Nate Kaeding
TD: Green Bay Packers




Team 2 Yahoo Auction Draft Standard 10 man League, 4pt PTD, 6pt for all other TD, non-PPR, 25yard/1pt

1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1 Def

QB: Michael Vick, Joe Flacco
RB: Arian Foster, Maurice Jones-Drew, BenJarvus Green-Ellis, LaDainian Tomlinson
WR: Roddy White, Mike Wallace, Johnny Knox, Braylon Edwards, Roy Williams
TE: Rob Gronkowski, Brandon Pettigrew
PK: Neil Rackers
TD: Green Bay Packers




Team 3 ESPN Auction Draft, standard rule like Yahoo, 4pt PTD, 6pt for all other TD, non-PPR, 25yard/1pt
but different starter,

1QB 2RB 2WR 1TE 1K 1R/W flex 1Def

QB: Aaron Rodgers, Mark Sanchez
RB: Rashard Mendenhall, Frank Gore, Darren Sproles
R/W flex: Matt Forte
WR: DeSean Jackson, Mike Williams TB, Lee Evans, Malcom Floyd, Mike Williams, Deion Branch
TE: Greg Olsen, Tony Gonzalez
PK: Sebastian Janikowski
TD: St. Louis Rams



Regarding team 2. do you think BJGE will be able to cover for Foster's missing weeks?

[Chaoyi Shih]

bump for honest comment

[joheshy55]

TEAM 1:
QB's Good especially with brees having so many options whether it be in back feild for screen passing or wr core options such as graham, henderson, moore maechem....etc
RB's im not sure if i like MJD as a number 1 only cuz hes off a knee injury and is hurt a lot. Plus number 2 rb back option is more like a number 3 or flex option in most leagues. So basically you may be in serious trouble. Only reason i say that is cuz beanie wells hasnt proven himself yet and ryan grant has shown that much in preseason and the role of starks and that guy from hawaii are coming in to play probably mid season. Plus rogers loves to throw the ball anyway.
WR core is awesome you may be able to put in a trade greg jennings or wayne for a better number 2 back or get 2 for one or jennings and grant wayne and grant for possibly better option at number 2 back and maybe someone worth wr3 spot.
TE dont have to say anything clark and olsen are both good and could both be starters in most leagues i think.
KICKER and DEF change year to year so im not gonna rate any of them.

TEAM 2
QB's Great
RB' way more balanced than team 1. i do believe green ellis will be able to fill the need for foster only cuz if foster does play his injury could effect his play regardless. NO worries there.
WR's great all around, i like knox on your team he should do well i think at bears with addition of roy williams.
TE's good but may have to choose week to week.

Team 3
Pretty much all around equivelent to number 2 team. Balanced. TE may have to switch week to week.

[Chaoyi Shih]

thank you for team1 advice

i am thinking trade wayne or r jenning for one of the RB

the other team have Forte, Gore, CJ2K, Greene, Hillis
he tried to trade Hillis for AJohnson before and i rejected it.
His WR are DeSean Jackson, Julio Jones and Bodin

what trade i should offer
Beanie+Ajohnson for DeSean+Gore?
Wayne for Forte?

Please give me you opinion