Thanks for helping mine. It definitely sounds like you want to do the deal, but I probably would hold off. I am a big fan of Finley and feel like you are giving up a lot. In PPR you can make the argument that Lesean Mccoy is more valuable than Chris Johnson. Additionally, there is no guarantee that you are going to be significantly upgrading over Charles by having CJ2K. I think the issue is not that you are trading from positions of depth to get a stud, but that you are downgrading at other positions without significantly improving at the other. I think that you can argue that your TE depth provides you with other TE 1 options, but Finley has the potential to be such a huge advantage at that position. Additionally, while I am not a huge fan of Marshall, I think that he provides great value at WR3, and you are definitely downgrading there. Your RB3 goes up significantly, but assuming you only start 2, it doesn't make much sense to have three stud rbs, at the cost of two other positions.