Which Roster Looks Better?

[illad3lph]

I am potentially trading away Jermichael Finley, Brandon Marshall, and Ryan Mathews for CJ2K. Is it worth it? I am in a 12 team PPR DYNASTY where the lineup requirements are QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1 TE, 2 FLEX (RB,TE,WR), 1 K, 1 DEF. Here are the rosters

Here is my current roster:

QBS
Mike Vick
Big Ben
Eli Manning

RB
Jamaal Charles
Lesean McCoy
Ryan Mathews
Ryan Torain
Ricky Williams

WR
Larry Fitzgerald
Calvin Johnson
Brandon Marshall
Lance Moore
Danny Amendola
Steve Breaston
Antonio Brown
Jason HIll
Jabar Gaffney
Vincent Brown
Mike Williams (SEA)

TE
Jermichael Finley
Rob Gronkowski
Aaron Hernandez
Jared Cook
Julius Thomas

K
Nate Kaeding

NO DEF YET


or

Here is my future roster:

QBS
Mike Vick
Big Ben
Eli Manning

RB
Jamaal Charles
Lesean McCoy
Ryan Mathews
Chris Johnson
Javon RInger
Ricky Williams

WR
Larry Fitzgerald
Calvin Johnson
Lance Moore
Danny Amendola
Steve Breaston
Jason HIll
Jabar Gaffney
Vincent Brown
Mike Williams (SEA)

TE
Rob Gronkowski
Aaron Hernandez
Jared Cook
Julius Thomas
Kevin Boss

K
Nate Kaeding

NO DEF YET

[thebigsmooth]

i would stay put with what you have right now. This has to be an 8 team league?

Good luck. Please take a look at mine

viewtopic.php?f=44&t=494146

[illad3lph]

Wait, which one, I accidentally said both were my current roster.` 1st or 2nd?

And no, this is a 12 team league.

[nimzox]

Thanks for your thoughts on mine. Normally, I would say don't make this trade, but you have Fitz and Calvin on your squad. Chris Johnson would definitely be a nice addition to your team, so if you really want him, go for it. You also might want to look into picking up Lance Kendricks (if he is available) to replace Finley. Good luck!

[illad3lph]

So the addition of Chris Johnson outweighs the LOSS of Brandon Marshall and Finley?

[Irish Drunk]

This team is stacked for a 12 teamer. I wouldn't change a thing. Giving all that up for CJ2K who is a higher risk than normal, isn't worth it. Mathews is going to bust out this year and Finley is the best TE in the league.

Stand pat.

[ilikeike]

That team looks crazy good for a 12 team league. I wouldn't touch a thing.

[ramzstriker]

I have no idea how you pulled this team off in a 12 team league. Great job. I agree with the post above, I would not change a thing. Running back is already a strength for you and I dont think you should give up balance to improve a proven commodity. Great job drafting, I am amazed at this team for the format and you should dominate.