I have a huge man crush on both of these WRs so I need to double check before I hit accept. I Trade Charles 2nd 2012 (INSTEAD OF Britt) for Wallace Tampa Mike Williams
My WRs are awful but my RBs are much stronger...thoughts? My Team Freeman, Josh TBB QB Newton, Cam CAR QB (R) Charles, Jamaal KCC RB Gerhart, Toby MIN RB (P) Goodson, Mike CAR RB Hightower, Tim WAS RB Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB Scott, Bernard CIN RB (P) Stewart, Jonathan CAR RB Branch, Deion NEP WR Britt, Kenny TEN WR (P) Brown, Antonio PIT WR Evans, Lee BAL WR (Q) Floyd, Malcom SDC WR (P) Gibson, Brandon STL WR (Q) Royal, Eddie DEN WR Sanders, Emmanuel PIT WR (P) Thomas, Demaryius DEN WR (Q) Williams, Mike SEA WR (P) Cooley, Chris WAS TE (Q) Gates, Antonio SDC TE (P) Thomas, Julius DEN TE (R) Henery, Alex PHI PK (R)
Last edited by 11stever11 on Mon Sep 05, 2011 7:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
No way do I make that trade. I think M. Williams TDs are likely to go down a bit this year, and at the end of the season if Britt stays healthy he and Williams will be pretty close in the rankings, so to me this trade isn't a whole lot better than Charles for Wallace straight up, which would be insane. Charles was the number 3 RB last year and his touches should go up this year, his upside is through the roof.
Also, no question you're good at RB right now, but take Charles out of that mix and then you've got Mendy and a bunch of question marks.
Stay far away from this one. Sanders and Brown, whoever is healthy and starts, are going to get some of Wallace's deep looks. And Williams doesn't make it equal for Charles.
Gotta say I agree with the overall response so far. I personally like mike wallace a lot. I think hes gonna have another potential top 5 year. I want a larger sample size from Mike Williams though. Jamaal Charles is a guy that could* be the #1 back when its all said and done. His big play potential + ability to catch balls out of the back means that hes basically matchup proof. I understand that your concern @ wr, so maybe try to see what kind of return you could get for Mendy. A lot of people are calling for a decrease in his production this year, so it might be wise to try to sell high based on his production last year. Goodluck
snaddles wrote:Gotta say I agree with the overall response so far. I personally like mike wallace a lot. I think hes gonna have another potential top 5 year. I want a larger sample size from Mike Williams though. Jamaal Charles is a guy that could* be the #1 back when its all said and done. His big play potential + ability to catch balls out of the back means that hes basically matchup proof. I understand that your concern @ wr, so maybe try to see what kind of return you could get for Mendy. A lot of people are calling for a decrease in his production this year, so it might be wise to try to sell high based on his production last year. Goodluck
Completely agree.
Do not make the trade, you are giving up too much.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by 
