I followed your advice, THANKS. After much research on the two... I dropped Orton and picked up Cutler.
I normally play week-to-week when I need a fill-in just to get some wins while the dust settles on a lot of situations. However, Ortons advantage over Cutler for week 1 seemed negligible. Orton is playing against a weaker secondary, but he's got a run heavy coach now. I also expect that game to be lower scoring overall. Whereas Cutler may have a tougher time, but he also might hit Knox for a 80yd TD in a single play attempting to catch up to Atlanta's offense. So, they seemed like a wash this week, I picked up Cutler because aside from this week, he is by far the best potential of the two. In fact, if what I've been reading about Cutler and his receivers is true, he may surpass Bradford as my main starter. Either way, none will replace Manning.