Vick/Moreno for Charles/Romo? WHIR

[omikron]

Who wins this trade in a PPR league with 6pt TD passes?

Michael Vick
Knowshon Moreno

FOR

Jamaal Charles
Tony Romo

[etl1692]

Not much difference. I like it. Iam not a fan of Vick for injury reasons. I think Romo will be solid this year he is healthy and ready to play. Clearly Charles is better than Moreno.


viewtopic.php?f=18&t=495226

[Ball Movements]

I would take Charles/Romo.

I think Vick is going to take a step down this year. The OL is not nearly as good as last year and is not going to give him the protection he needs.

Charles is a definite upgrade over Moreno. McGahee is going to steal most of the TDs away from Moreno.

[JRoZe628]

Id take the Charles and Romo side over the Vick side.

Help:http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=495260

[Osk]

Charles/Romo are both elite starters. Vick is super elite, but moreno? Not so much. Seems like an easy choice to me.

[schmidty]

Charles/Romo side easily (and from my helmet, you can see I'm even an Eagles homer). Romo's injury has some people forgetting how elite a fantasy option he is. I wouldn't be surprised if Romo outpoints Vick this year. Plus, Charles >>>> Moreno.

Help in return? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=495271