Post the rest of your roster and your opponents roster. I would rather wait until later in to the season to get down to roster strength rankings to make decisions but Peyton has seriously f*cked a lot of people.
Bottom line is if the rest of your team is more solid than your opponent go with a safe qb like orton/hasselbeck because they have strong run games and wont be called upon to make a lot plays (higher upside for orton). If you think you are going to get beat then you have to go high risk/reward with someone like fitzpatrick.
10 Team Std Scoring No PPR
WR Julio Jones
WR Dez Bryant
K and Def by committee
Jordy Nelson, Ben Tate, David Nelson, Kendall Hunter, John Dwyer