MJD & Schaub for Vick, Vy, and Lynch HELP! =)

[bhov97]

Trading Schaub and MJD for Vick, Vince Young, and Marshawn Lynch...
Need Feedback please assist!


QB Matt Schaub, Hou QB

RB Darren McFadden, Oak RB

RB Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac RB

RB/WR DeAngelo Williams, Car RB

WR DeSean Jackson, Phi WR

WR Santana Moss, Wsh WR

TE Vernon Davis, SF TE

D/ST Packers D/ST D/ST

K Josh Brown, StL K


Bench Donald Driver, GB WR

Bench Santana Moss, Wsh WR

Bench Michael Bush, Oak RB

Bench Plaxico Burress, NYJ WR

Bench Reggie Bush, Mia RB

Bench A.J. Green, Cin WR

Bench Tony Gonzalez, Atl TE

Bench Donovan McNabb, Min QB

[TaDa]

Bad trade for you. For the few slots up that you'd get in Vick at QB, you're taking way too big of a loss on the RB side.

[Ball Movements]

Agree..... I wouldn't do that trade.

[Indibuck]

Pass.

[latsprewell20002000]

Horrific trade for you. Not only do you get slaughtered on the MJD part, but you could even be losing with giving up Schaub. I would bet that Schaub has more points at the end of the year than Vick does. Remember Vick only plays like 12/16 games a year. He WILL miss some games. I dont know I would just rather have MJD and Schaub, and by a long shot.

[dtownsound8]

Here's what worries me with Vick... it's not so much that he'll probably miss a couple games or so it's that as the season progresses and he takes more beatings with his play style, it becomes more and more likely to happen.

Can you go a couple games without him in order to get the monster points he'll put up in other weeks? probably... but what if those weeks he misses are in the playoffs? TERRIBLE SCENERIO

If you were going from Flacco to Vick I'd say HELLS YES BRO but Schaub should put up enough points to give you a decent edge at the QB position most weeks.


This just isn't worth the downgrade you take at RB.



help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=495408