Who SUFFERS Most? S.Smith(CAR) or Garcon!! WHIR

[Idubthe]

I know Berry always says, " Just Start the Higher Ranked Player". I'm not sure if im alone on this or not, but I don't think the Colts WR are going to suffer that much. Sure some. If I were a player, I'd take the wiley ol' veteran over the inaccurate Running Rookie. Who will run under pressure and not get rid of the ball that quick. Smith only scored double digits twice last season. Game 1 and 2 all be it. I'm not sure how bad Collie is beat up, but I know Garcon will get looks. Just not as many as Smith. Please someone pour some decision spice on this subject WHIR to the best of my abilities.

P.S. Just for reassurance , DeAngelo Williams over Mike Tolbert or do the goal line punches out weigh the elusive big play?

Thanks in advance. Drop a link for help.

[Stevooo]

Newton hurts Smith more. His instinct will be to pull down and run soon as things turn bad. You saw him in the pre season. Collie is set to play so Garcon will get fewer touches. This is a really tough choice but I would go with Garcon just be cause Collins will make better decisions than Cam, for now at least.

[rclement3915]

Id roll with Smith.... despite the rookie QB situation, hes the clear cut #1 and has homerun ability. His upside IMO, is much higher than Kerry Collins' 4th or 5th option in his 1st game in Indy's offense.

help me out with my wideouts:
viewtopic.php?t=495524

[twes]

Garcon is a pure talent and even though his QB is out for the season, you should still be fine with him.

Obviously don’t start him week 1 or anything but give it some time.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=19&t=495525