2 TRADES: Which is Better? WHIR 100%

[war106]

This is a 12 team, .5 PPR League

Trade 1:

I GIVE: Jahvid Best
I GET: Santonio Holmes

Trade 2:

I GIVE: Matt Forte
I GET: Vincent Jackson

Here's my team:

QB: Rodgers
QB: Kolb (We start 2)
WR: Brandon Marshall
WR: Mario Manningham
WR: Braylon Edwards
RB: DMC
RB: Forte
TE: Cook/Lewis
W/T: AJ Green
W/R: Jahvid Best

Bench:
Willis McGahee
Antonio Brown
Michael Bush
Devery Henderson

[britdevine]

I'm not getting rid of Forte this year, certainly not in that deal.

You do need WR help, but not that bad since your HB's are pass catching monsters as well.

I wouldn't do either..if your looking for WR help, I would move Rodgers + a WR for a slight downgrade at QB + an upgrade at WR.

I like your team as is though.

Help?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=495899&p=3341005#p3341005

[mcrow]

Both trades are bad trades for you.

Forte will score as many points each week as the two players (combined)you could choose from here.

[c0megets0me]

Best for Holmes............NO and Forte for Vjax..........NO, However I would do Best for Vjax

[mojoorising]

If i have to pick one go with A, but like everyone said that is a bad trade as well. Try packaging up Best with Braylon for V Jax and hope he goes for it.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=495923