Trade Question for the experts

[roberts1313]

Quick Question for the experts.

Proposed trade:

I give L. McCoy (RB)
I get V. Jackson (WR)

My counter offer:
L. McCoy (RB) for C. Johnson (WR)

Background I have J. Charles, A. Bouldin, S. Moss, L. , M.S. Walker, Blount, T, Hightower, and others if you care

What do you guys think?

R

[c0megets0me]

Cancel all those trade ASAP........Dont give up McCoy for any wr's....NONE!

[Ozymandias19]

Who are your other RBs? Megatron is the best WR in the game, but it depends on what you have outside of McCoy.

[roberts1313]

Other RB's
L. McCoy
Jamal Charles
LeGarrette Blount
Tim Hightower
Knowshown Moreno
Derrick Ward

Rest of team
Phillip Rivers
Anquan Boldin
Santana Moss
Mike Sims-Walker
Jermichael Finley(GB - TE)
Jacoby Ford(Oak - WR)
Jordy Nelson(GB - WR)
Mark Sanchez(NYJ - QB)
Devery Henderson

[roberts1313]

As you can see I could use some WR help

This is not how I would have drafted (Autodraft)

[Ozymandias19]

Charles wouldn't work? Or Charles and Moss? I know you are short at WR, but you would be getting Megatron, and I'm sure you can find someone to replace Moss's production on the WW. Either way, I would think long and hard about a Megatron for McCoy trade. That's a tough one. I think I would do it.

[roberts1313]

Not sure if he would take Charles (actually I would prefer it). I actually like McCoy a little more. I am trying to get one of his big WR (C. Johnson or Andre Johnson), although so far he has only offered V. Jackson (who I like but not at that price). Ultimately, if he is willing to part with Calvin or Andre, I will likely give him either Charles or McCoy.

Charles wouldn't work? Or Charles and Moss? I know you are short at WR, but you would be getting Megatron, and I'm sure you can find someone to replace Moss's production on the WW. Either way, I would think long and hard about a Megatron for McCoy trade. That's a tough one. I think I would do it.

[roberts1313]

So he made his offer:

He gets: L. McCoy (RB)
I get:V. Jackson (WR)

Nothing against VJ but I think I am going to pass unless he can give me something else with VJ.

R

[LSUSaint]

You would be getting ripped for giving up a potential top 5 back for Vjax.

[roberts1313]

agreed. Just rejected it.