******* BIG trade decesion? ********

[shaba]

I really want Mcfadden & have worked out this trade w/ his team owner.

I receive Mcfadden & Ben Watson
&
He receives Hillis & Gates.

I know I take a downgrade at the TE position but do have Lance Kendricks & who id start over Watson.

This is a PPR league & here is my team.

Stafford
Forte
Hillis
Calvin Johnson
Welker
Manninghan
Gates
Carpenter
Giants D

Bench
Flacco
Mcgahee
Starks
Hardesty
Jordy Nelson
Julio jones
lance kendricks

I just think run dmc is going to have a better year than Hillis. So do I pull the Trigger or stay put thnx.

[monkiesatemybaby]

Keep in mind Hillis had 6 catches, which is worth 60 yds rushing in PPR. McFadden only had 2 more points than Hillis even with all those rushing yds. Gates consistently leads his team in targets. I like Hillis and DMac, I'm not so sure one is a huge upgrade over the other IMO. Good luck!

Can a brother get a hand?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=496123

[pbfrk4life]

I love Run DMC but he and Hillis will have similar years and gates is ELITE. I dont like the trade.

Help Plz posting.php?mode=post&f=18

[Chaoyi Shih]

normally i am all for better QB, RB and WR, and go easy on TE, but in this case, i don't think upgrade from Hillis to DMC is enough to cover the downgrade from Gate to Kendrick

you going from semi-stud RB to almost-stud RB, but this almost-stud RB have bad injury record, and you never know when it will hit you. upside is when DMC is good, he is a monster.

and you going from top stud TE to waiver TE, you can even find better TE than Kendrick in some league.

unless you have huge crash on DMC, otherwise, save Hillis and Gate, they should get more score than DMC+waiver TE