S. Smith (Car) for Mendenhall?

[SeahawkSuperbowl'11]

Thinking about offering S. Smith for Mendenhall? Basically just wondering if you all think that S. Smith's performance was a fluke? If not then he maw have a monster year... Can Mendenhall bounce back or are the Steelers really that bad this year?

[rclement3915]

1. I dont think Steve Smith will produce like that weekly, but may be a solid wr2.
2. Mendenhall should def bounce back, the Steelers will NOT be that bad and will NOT face a fired up defense like the Ravens' every week... i think he and the steelers bounce back big this week.

If the person with Mendenhall is stupid enough to do it... go for it, hes a top 10-15 RB.

[SeahawkSuperbowl'11]

Not sure he will but he is weak at WR. Thanks for the input.

[SeahawkSuperbowl'11]

He sent me a counteroffer, its now Ryan Mathews and Steve Smith for Mendenhall...?

[rclement3915]

whats the rest of your roster look like???


also help me out:
viewtopic.php?t=496162

[Chaoyi Shih]

despite how bad Mendenhall and Steeler is on week1, Mendenhall is still a top10 RB

elite player bust, but 1 bad week shouldn't be the judge.
Roddy, Gore both had bad week1, i won't trade Roddy for Tolbert or Gore for C.Henne

you should take his offer and run.
imo, he either truly believe S. Smith+Newton will become new Rodger+Jenning or Manning+Wayne, or he just underestimate Mendenhall by looking at his week1 performance.