Tolbert is the goal-line back for a high powered offense, so he'd be my first choice. Then probably Hightower, Benson. That's if you're looking long-term, if you want a short term fix....Tolbert, Caddy, Hightower, Benson. Hard for me to buy Buffalo after one game, but F-Jax is no slouch either tbh.
16 Team .5 PPR
QB-Josh Freeman(Andy Dalton)
RB/WR-Rashard Mendenhall(Shonn Greene)
RB/WR-Ben Tate(Deji Karim)
WR/TE-Kenny Britt(Jacoby Ford)
WR/TE-Steve Smith, CAR
TE-Dustin Keller(Tony Scheffler)