waiver#2 Steve Smith, C. Williams, or Starks?

[kieu]

I have waiver #2 and I feel like I need a RB/Flex badly. Can't decide between Steve Smith, Cadillac Williams, or Starks
QB: Romo
WR: Megatron
WR: V. Jackson
RB: Felix Jones
RB: BenJarvus
TE: Jermichael Finley
WR/RB: Santonio Holmes

Bench: Deangelo Williams
Bench: Matt Schaub
Bench: Ron Gronkowski
Bench: Marshawn Lynch
Bench: Lance Moore

[sheethappens]

Here's a very similar thread for you to look at:

viewtopic.php?t=496245



In short, Caddy is only a 1 or 2 week fill-in, Starks is a backup on his own team and not going to see significant time, and Smith has a rookie QB that is going to be up and down. Smith is the only one of the three who is an established #1 and starter on his team. IMO he's the only one worth spending a roster spot on but until Newton proves himself I'd be hesitant to start him on my team.

[ATLbraves]

In short, Caddy is only a 1 or 2 week fill-in, Starks is a backup on his own team and not going to see significant time, and Smith has a rookie QB that is going to be up and down. Smith is the only one of the three who is an established #1 and starter on his team. IMO he's the only one worth spending a roster spot on but until Newton proves himself I'd be hesitant to start him on my team.

Completely agree.

If you need a short-term fill in, then go with Caddy. If you are looking long term, then go with Steve Smith.


help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=496207