Drop Peyton Manning for Eli Manning?

[TurkeyTime]

This question has probably been asked 1,000 times, but I need the help now. I have Kevin Kolb, but I don't think he's a solid enough option to take me to the promised land. I have no backup QB who is available to play right now. Peyton Manning has been occupying a spot on my bench since I traded for him and the Packers DST.

I would think that the Colts would need to be in contention for them to bring Manning back this year, otherwise why risk a career ending injury for a team not headed to the playoffs? IF Peyton comes back, how effective will he really be?

Should I pick up Eli Manning off of waivers and drop Peyton Manning (or who do you see I could drop in place of Peyton)? Your thoughts please

Scoring,
25 yds passing- 1 point
td- 6 points
10 yds rushing- 1 point

Start- QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, K, DEF

QB Kevin Kolb (ARI)
QB- Peyton Manning (IND)
RB- Chris Johnson (TEN)
RB- Jahvid Best (DET)
RB- DeAngelo Williams (CAR)
RB- James Starks (GB)
WR- Andre Johnson (HOU)
WR- Hakeem Nicks (NYG)
WR- Julio Jones (ATL)
WR- Mike Thomas (JAC)
WR- Robert Meachem (NO)
TE- Antonio Gates (SD)
K- John Kasay (NO)
DEF- Packers

[riotide]

I'm an advocate of dropping Manning unless you have an IR slot. I just don't see him playing this year. Why would the Colts bring Peyton back with 4 or less games to play when his health and a high draft pick would be in jeopardy and the season will already be lost? Eli would be nice to have and you could keep Kolb to play match ups all year.

help me if you can: viewtopic.php?t=496603