I'd go Addai here. Cleveland let up a ton of yards to Benson. The Colts are not looking pretty, so I think a lot of the offense should run through Addai. He'll also probably get more receptions than Ingram. I'd say they're about the same chances at getting a TD, because while Ingram might get goal line duties, no ones gonna take them from Addai while he's healthy. Plus, he's going to get hurt sooner or later, might as well use him while he's healthy.
Lend a hand?