MySchaub/VJAX/Hester/Ringer 4 Vick/MarioM/Addai/JJones(WHIR)

[bearsfan50]

League specs:

Rush/Rec td = 6pts
Pass TD = 4pts

ppr = .5

Rush/rec yds = 1pt per 10 yds
Pass yds = 1pt per 20 yds

My roster:
QB: Schaub, Sanchez
RB: RRice, SJAX, Bradshaw, TJones, Ringer, DThomas
WR: VJAX, Britt, Meachem, Hester, Royal, Gaffney
TE: Daniels, Celek
K: Rackers, Scobee
DEF: TB, Minn

Do I accept the trade? I like the point explosion of Vick, but I hate giving up VJAX (who I think will have a good year) and will Vick really outscore Schaub by a wide margin?

Oops, I forgot to mention that it's James Jones not Julio Jones and it's a re-draft league.

If you help me, I will help you. Thanks

[JaysFan]

I would keep Schaub and Vjax. if it's keeper I'd be tempted since Julio Jones could be great....

[pangbones]

At first I thought no way, but after thinking about it, I think I would do it. Vick is more valuable in a 4 pt per pass TD league, cuz he will run in 5-10 TD's. I like Manningham, and Addai is much better than Hester and Ringer at the moment. I think it's close, but I'd rather have Vick and Manningham in my lineup each week, with Addai on my bench. It's close though.

Heres mine
viewtopic.php?t=497044

[BearsFan65]

Thanks for the help with mine. I'd do the deal, much as it would hurt to give up VJax. pangbones has it right - with pass td's = 4, Vick's relative value to Schaub is a lot higher than if they're 6. Manningham is steady (though I don't like his QB at all this year), and Addai is a more useful piece than either Hester or Ringer at this point. I think you gain more at QB than you lose at WR. Good luck!

[Aberfoyle]

I would want to own the vick side of the trade. For what you lose in Vincent Jackson over Mario, you make up with addai and jjones.

[2b-or-not-2b]

Yes, make the deal quick before the other owner changes their mind!!

Vick has more value than Schaub. Houston wants to be run first and when Foster comes back their wish will come true. If Vick can take the hits (from defenses, not a bong) he will significantly outscore Schaub over the season.

Rice is a workhorse. He and Vick will more than cover what you might be giving up in the other players.

Trade! Trade! Trade!!