CJ and Jordy Nelson for Mike Wallace and Ryan Matthews? WHIR

[snaddles]

J Charles just went down. I have AP and CJ left as my rbs (auction league). WRs are Bmarsh and Jordy Nelson. Should I do this deal?

[bazzy_51]

Do not understand why you would even think about this deal?

It's an even swap, 2 for 2, so you add no depth and in my eyes lose value. Yes Wallace would be a nice upgrade over Jordy, but Nelson is no longer only a WR in 4WR sets for GB. He is a solid option for Rogers, and Rogers is definitely looking his way when hes on the field. So to say Jordy can't reach 750-900yds this year, imo, is not a big reach.

Even if Wallace was a HUGE upgrade over Jordy, going from CJ to Matthews is a huge drop. Your talking about a top 5 pick for what a 4th-6th rounder? No point in doing this deal. I really think there is another trade out there if you want to deal CJ to upgrade your WR and get another player to help your lineup elsewhere.

I would want more if I were dealing CJ.

[snaddles]

i guess a big part is that after this week, ill be 0-2 and i feel like i dont have that much time to wait around for cj. i was able to catch the game today and it just didnt look like he was running well

[bazzy_51]

i guess a big part is that after this week, ill be 0-2 and i feel like i dont have that much time to wait around for cj. i was able to catch the game today and it just didnt look like he was running well

Only two things I can say about this week at least:

1. It was Baltimore, I mean no one looks very good against that D, even Mendy looked like crap last week against them, and Pitt has a much stronger o-line then Tennessee.
2. Week 1 against the Jags they played down the whole game and looking at the Jags run D, its not too shaby. Held Shonn Green and LT combined to a sub 3 yds per carry today.

I really think you need to give CJ more then 2 weeks to prove himself. Next week should be a redeem week, but you probably won't agree with me until after the bye. But any RB whose schedule means going up against Baltimore and Pitt in the first four weeks is not going to get out of the gates too hot.

[snaddles]

i hear ya - thanks for the feedback

[riotide]

I agree, I don't think you can abandon hope with CJ.

Help me if you can: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=497621&p=3349350#p3349350

[MadDog36]

No way bro. You need to keep what you got. Post your complete roster and what is in FA please since you have CHarles you have a need.

[snaddles]

Complete Roster:

QB: Cutler
RB: ADP
RB: CJ
RB/WR: ?
WR: Marshall
WR: J. Nelson
TE: Olsen
K: Brown
DEF: SD


Bench

Knox
Amendola
Demarco Murray
Lance Kendricks
Chad Henne
Deji Karim

Notable FA's

Thomas Jones
Eric Decker
Gaffney
Nate Washington

[MadDog36]

Most definitely cut Amendola for Thomas Jones QUICKLY.