Trade purposed to me WHIR

[hensch_dog]

12 Team PPR league

I would get:
P. Rivers
Ray Rice
Ricky Williams

I would give up:
Kevin Kolb
Chris Johnson
Beanie Wells
Deion Branch


My starters include:
Kolb
P. Hillis
C. Johnson
B. Wells (FLEX)
K. Britt
S. Moss
Jason Witten

Please let me know your thoughts, opinions, and advice. Thanks.

[WaCougMBS]

As much as I love Rice, I would stay put in this case. Handcuffing the BAL backfield is a step backwards from CJ and Beanie for sure, and I'm not convinced the difference between Rivers and Kolb is nearly enough to justify this deal. Branch is only like a WR4 in fantasy, but still it's just another piece that unbalances the trade further. Only way I deal with this guy for your 4 players listed is if the second RB you get back in return is a heckuva lot better than Ricky. Can you post your full roster as well as the other guy's?

[hensch_dog]

Thank you for your reply. I agree in a sense that I feel like I would need more. I lose my flex starter in Beanie Wells. Chris Johnson HAS been slow to start, and Kolb has shown consistency in his first two games. Here are the rosters of both teams.

My team
Henne
Kolb
Hillis
C Johnson
Wells
Britt
S Moss
J. Witten
D Branch
MSW
D. Amendola
Jerome Simpson
Pierre Thomas


His team includes
Rivers
Rice
Jamaal Charles
Reggie Wayne
Nate Washington
Jacoby Jones
Gronkowski
Jacoby Ford
Ricky Williams
Ladinan Tomlinson
and Emanuel Sanders

[rdj3385]

I would have to second the previous response. I wouldnt sell CJ and Beanie for a slight upgrade at QB. CJ should turn it around. Stand pat.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=497684