Mark Ingram for Ben Tate Trade... Who You Got???

[RobustPerry]

I'm in a 10 team PPR that starts 3 wr, 2 rb, 1 te & 1 flex. My team's as follows and wanted advice on a trade:

QB: Kolb & Bradford
WR: Roddy White, Austin Miles, Dez Bryant (bench David Nelson)
RB: Darren McFadden, Peyton Hillis, Javid Best (bench Ryan Matthews, Ben Tate and Michael Bush)
TE: Jimmy Graham

I've been offered Mark Ingram for Ben Tate


My thoughts are...

Trade could be great if Foster comes back, Tate is relegated to back up getting 5-10 carries and Ingram starts tearing it up once the Saints get into easier portion of the schedule & once he's gets more experience.

Trade could be horrible if Ingram stays in that 50 yd/game range with little chance of a TD and Foster's out a lot and Tate becomes a top 10 back

What do you think?

[RobustPerry]

thoughts

[cubanrob19]

I like Tate better ... Even if Foster comes back healthy and 100%, Kubiak already has seen how productive he is, so he will still play him a good amount even with Foster in. Also, as you saw Foster re-aggrevated his hamstring, and I have a feeling that it will be an on and off thing the whole season. I stay with Tate.
Offer him Michael Bush! lol

[johnhoefer]

Keep Tate. If anything try to upgrade at QB.