I'd stay put man. I love Staffords potential this year, I think he could throw 30-35 TDs. But, I think you are loosing too much on the rest of the trade to be worth it. Ben's schedule the coming weeks is cake (IND, HOU, TEN, JAC, ARI) so I think he will step up his production. I'd stay put and wait for Colston to return.
I actually like the trade for you. I think Stafford is an upgrade over Ben. And Thomas as a 3rd RB is also an upgrade.
Obviously losing Colston isn't ideal, but there's no telling how quickly he's going to come back from the injury or how productive he's going to be if he does play. I'd make the deal.
Increase value at QB Decrease value at RB (but good upside) Decrease value at WR a bit.
Not sure I would do it. Too many questions surrounding how involved Thomas will actually be in Miami with Reggie Bush in the picture. I think you would be giving up too much in Colston. Stafford is good, arguably better than Big Ben. He's just injury prone and not sure I would take the risk.
wow, it is a touch decision - I think Stafford is definitely on his way up. The injuries over the past few years would scare me a bit but Eli I think will put up decent numbers. I guess I would do it but just slightly.