Ugh I have both of these guys and am sort of in similar situation. It's a wash I think... I think Tate is the logical choice if you say hey who is #1, who will be the lead back, who will get more carries. Tolbert is in a good situation vs KC though to steal TD's from Matthews and catch a lot of passes. Not to mention he might be pounding the ball late in the game if they are up a lot and want to protect Matthews. I have a soft spot for Tolbert... I hope it doesn't burn me this week. My only fear is that they might let Ryan Matthews strut his stuff vs KC for experience/confidence.
QB: M. Stafford, T. Pryor
RB: J. Charles, Chris Johnson, D. Sproles, Ben Tate, Willis McGahee
WR:J. Nelson, A. Boldin, J. Gordon, P. Harvin, H. Douglas, T. Williams
TE: J. Witten, J. Cameron
K: G. Hartley