roddy white for fred jackson? WHIR 100%

[sabomnim]

someone offered me fred jackson for roddy white (i currently have roddy)?
my RBs are garbage after charles's injury
am i crazy for considering it?
non-ppr

WR:
roddy white
mike wallace
maclin
colston
plaxico
santana moss

RB:
blount
benson
daniel thomas
mccluster
knowshon moreno


i can try to counter, here are his RBs
forte
mcfadden
hillis
fred jackson

[scalqq]

I think Hillis for Roddy White is fair, Fred Jackson's production so far is not sustainable at all (considering they played two weak defensive teams thus far) - seems like Roddy's production has taken a hit, as well, with the arrival of Julio Jones.

Again, I like Hillis for Roddy White.

Could use some help with my situation: viewtopic.php?t=498507

[Chaoyi Shih]

Hillis is most even and fair
if he give you F.Jackson, you should offer Maclin/Colston instead, even he probably won't take it

[MadDog36]

Colston for FJax is very fair.
If he wants White tell him to pony up Hillis.

[howard]

I wouldn't do that move. I agree that Hillis for White would be better or even Forte for White. I don't like FJax, I think Spiller will get more carries as the year goes on. Yeah, he had a good week last week, but thats why your opponent is trying to sell high.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=498517

[Chaoyi Shih]

or hold White for few more week and hope he pick up the points, after all, you can easily trade White for Forte when season haven't started yet