Alright, after re-visiting this and realizing that Mendenhall is up against Indy, I don't see how you not play him. I go Blount and Mendenhall here.
QB: E. Manning, Bradford
RB: Peterson, Best, Tolbert, Starks, Torain
WR: Wallace, Welker,Colston. P. Parker, Floyd
TE: Hernandez, Davis