Is this an absurd trade? unfair? League ruining?

[eromano33]

Is this an absurd trade? Just looking for opinions: Stevie Johnson + Nate Washington for Andre Johnson, especially if the andre Owner has Desean as well and was looking for some kind of a stable option to go w. Desean?

[plapre3]

It's hard to say without knowing the setup of the league and other particulars, but I wouldn't call it absurd or league-ruining.

Basically the trade was a Stud for two solid starters. If a team were in a desperate situation and needed more depth at WR, the deal could make some sense. I wouldn't call it a good or fair trade, and I'd like to see someone get more for Johnson, but it would be reasonable

Full disclosure:
I believe that unless there is a clear case of collusion, all trades should happen freely in a league.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=500342

[sweettortilla]

I absolutely agree with the above. In all aspects, both the trade and my philosophy towards trading and allowing trades. Vetoing trades sucks and stifles the trading community.


Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=500347

[eromano33]

Thanks guys. I'll help you guys out at around 4 , I'm on my
Phone in class right now.