Roddy/Garcon for J. Stewart/Welker - WHIR!

[cspirk]

Should I do the following deal? I'm desperate for a RB2. It's a 12-team dynasty league. WHIR!!!

I give up:
Roddy White
Pierre Garcon

I get:
Jonathan Stewart
Wes Welker

Roster
1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 O-flex
QB - Rivers*, Campbell, Gabbert
RB - C. Johnson*, J. Charles (IR), K. Hunter*, J. Ringer, D. Karim, J. Forsett
WR - A. Johnson*, M. Austin, R. White*, N. Burleson, P. Garcon, L. Hankerson
TE - R. Gronkowski*, V. Davis*, D. Keller

[rclement3915]

hmmm... is it PPR or standard?

i dont like stewart at all...the carolina running game looks awful.

Roddy in a keeper league is tough to give up.


help me out:
viewtopic.php?t=500431

[cspirk]

PPR (0.5 per). Definitely would be taking a risk on J-Stew...

[JoeyBallgame]

J. Stewart is the riskiest part of this deal no doubt. D-Lo just got paid yet it looks like Stewart is gettin most of the touches. I personally wouldn't touch the Carolina running game if I didnt absolutely have to. Looking at your team Stewart would still be an upgrade over anything you have with Charles on IR. If you're confident in Welker staying healthy, which is tough, I would do the deal. If you value Roddy more with it being a Dynasty league, I would hold off.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=500453