Who wins in this trade? WHiR

[ilikefootball]

I want to send him Stafford, Gore, K. Hunter, Vincent Jackson and Fred Davis for his Vick, J. Best, Andre Johnson and Gates. I am not a fan of Vick, but I have backup QB with Flacco and Fitzpatrick in case Vick gets hurt. And Gates is basically worth nothing, just hold on to him and hope he gets better towards the middle of the season. What do you guys think? WHIR
10 player PPR league
Start- 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 WR/TE, 1 WR/RB
QB- Stafford, Flacco, Fitzpatrick
RB- McFadden, Gore, B Wells, Hightower and Michael Bush
WR- Vincent Jackson, Mike Wallace, Boldin, Mike Thomas, D. Moore, David Nelson
TE- Witten, F. Davis

[Ciobanu]

you will def. get the upper hand of this deal, Vick, Best, and Andre Johnson is a great addition to any team. Especially for what youre offering.

[mixreveal]

If the guy takes the trade then good for you but I don't think you're giving up enough to get what you're asking for. This is, of course, only my opinion.

[K0wned]

He's downgrading at everything besides QB and that is very close imo. Why would he do this?

[ilikefootball]

Ok so he says to balance out the trade he wants boldin in the trade and he throws in harvin. Will that balance it out and if it goes through will it be a good trade for me? Please help me out.

[DVauthrin]

Ok so he says to balance out the trade he wants boldin in the trade and he throws in harvin. Will that balance it out and if it goes through will it be a good trade for me? Please help me out.

make the deal. harvin and boldin aren't deal breakers here.

[PrinceEatMeat]

If he takes this you got a steal. You get the 4 best players in the deal.

[bricox171]

I want to send him Stafford, Gore, K. Hunter, Vincent Jackson and Fred Davis for his Vick, J. Best, Andre Johnson and Gates. I am not a fan of Vick, but I have backup QB with Flacco and Fitzpatrick in case Vick gets hurt. And Gates is basically worth nothing, just hold on to him and hope he gets better towards the middle of the season. What do you guys think? WHIR
10 player PPR league
Start- 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 WR/TE, 1 WR/RB
QB- Stafford, Flacco, Fitzpatrick
RB- McFadden, Gore, B Wells, Hightower and Michael Bush
WR- Vincent Jackson, Mike Wallace, Boldin, Mike Thomas, D. Moore, David Nelson
TE- Witten, F. Davis

What I dont understand here is how you think Gates is basically worth nothing. As long as he is not out for a substantial amount of time, he is still the best TE and will always have great value.

Anyways, that is a horribly lopsided trade, favoring you. But hey, if it works, it works. Go for it!

[ATLbraves]

Definitely make this deal if he is willing to accept. You win by far imo.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=500809

[bhova]

With Fitzpatrick as a back-up...

Pull the trigger. I like it