Mendy Trade WHIR

[11stever11]

12 Team, Dynasty

Who wins this trade?
Team 1
Santonio Holmes
Dan Sanzenbacher
1st 2012 Rookie Pick (mid range)

Team 2
Mendenhall

[NFL1527]

Team 2 for me. With these trades usually the team who receives the best player in the deal wins it and the players going back for Mendy other than Holmes aren't proven enough

[snixx79]

Team 2 for me. With these trades usually the team who receives the best player in the deal wins it and the players going back for Mendy other than Holmes aren't proven enough

Ditto. I take Mendy here 100 x out of 100. (i voted too!)

[DVauthrin]

give me mendenhall.

[saemick]

I don't think this is as simple as 1 side is better than the other just going of face value.

what do your other RB's look like? & when you say mid-range pick, we talking like pick 4 or pick 7...? I'm still leaning toward the Mendy side, but Holmes should be a good WR for at least a few more years, Sanz has the potential to be a decent slot receiver, and depending on what pick you're looking at, you could be getting a stud.

While I still like Mendy, he's had a ton of touches last year and PIT's O line looks awful.

So, on face, I'd take the Mendy side for sure, but if that draft pick could get as high as 3 or 4... then maybe I'd consider the other side of this trade

help:

viewtopic.php?t=500314