Is any one of my WRs worth giving up for Torrey Smith WHIR

[lamoac]

With Larry Fitzgerald and Calvin Johnson, my #1 & #2 WR spots are covered, but my #3 spot has been killing me. I recently reshuffled the rest of my receiver corp, acquiring Deion Branch, David Nelson , and Nate Washington.

I noticed that Torrey Smith is still unclaimed in my league, but I am suspicious of rookies. In my experience, they tend to be highly inconsistent putting up big numbers one week then disappearing for 2 or 3.

What are you feelings concerning Torrey Smith? Should I take a leap of faith and snatch him up before anyone else in my league does, or should I wait and see if he is the real deal? And if I do take a leap of faith, who should I give up for him?

Thanks for you help.

[PrinceEatMeat]

I like Smith. I picked him up myself. But I didn't have the WRs you have. I'd hold onto who you have.

Please help with mine!

viewtopic.php?t=500777

[bricox171]

I think you are better off keeping what you got. Rookie WR's are hard to judge. More often then not, they will post big numbers like Torrey did last week and then they become an afterthought in the following weeks.