Mendenhall or Tolbert

[Dublin1]

Okay, so I have a trading partner:

I originally request Mendehall for C. Johnson, straight up. He came back with the following:

M. Tolbert & J. Jones

for

R. Mendenhall & M. Manningham.

Mendenhall has not played well and Manningham is just becoming more and more useless. I'm planning to to pick up V. Cruz and drop J. Gaffney. I thought it was a little crazy, but this is my first fantasy football league and this guy is a veteran, so I'm wondering if he knows something I don't.

I still have:

V. Jackson
S. Smith
D. Branch
E. Graham (I'm trying to trade him and R. Grossman for F. Jackson, which may work!)

Your help will be very much appreciated. Thanks!