MJD for Austin trade opinion WHIR, complicate trade

[Chaoyi Shih]

standard yahoo rule, non-ppr, starting 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1Def 1K

that's me
team1
QB Vick/Fitspatrick
WR White/Wallace/N.Washington/V.Cruz/J.Knox/D.Henderson
RB Foster/MJD/Hillis/M.Bush
TE Gron


team2
QB Newton/Kolb
WR Welker/S.Smith/Austin/Ocho/B.Lloyd
RB BJGE/J.Stewart/F.Jones/R.Grant
TE O.Daniels

current trade is MJD/Knox for Austin/Grant
before week2 (before Foster comes back healthy), we had trade Newton/BJGE for Hillis/E.Manning, team1 need RB2 before Foster comes back, and team2 need a QB

now there's another trade, team1 want get a decent WR3, as you can see team1 got bunch decent WW WR knox, washington, cruz but non of them give enough production yet and with Foster back to 100%, having Hillis sitting on bench is a waste.

tried to proposed Hillis for Austin and got countered to current offer.
the only thing is if team1 take this offer, it's will be like
MJD/Newton/Knox/BJGE for Hillis/Austin/E.Manning/Grant (if we combine all trading history together)

but right now, the current trade is MJD/Knox for Austin/Grant
what's your opinion?

[gmoney973]

don't complicate things, i mean before week 2 with Cam only playing vs Arizona no one knew he would keep this up....


But doing this trade will hurt your RB depth, can u pick up Tate?

I'd still probably do this because the downgrade from MJD to Hillis is alil less then upgrade from your WR3 to Austin


viewtopic.php?f=18&t=501763

[Chaoyi Shih]

thx, any more comments?

[ATLbraves]

I like the MJD/Newton/Knox/BJGE for Hillis/Austin/E.Manning/Grant trade. You are getting a slight downgrade at RB but getting a HUGE upgrade at WR. So I would say go for that trade.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=502068

[Chaoyi Shih]

thx for reply, and keep on commenting

[MadDog36]

Hillis/Austin/E.Manning/Grant
I like this side a little more than what you give up. I like that your getting your RB depth replenished in this deal. I hate the original counter STAY AWAY!

[DVauthrin]

stay put. you need MJD more than you need Miles Austin.

[Chaoyi Shih]

thank you for all the comments
i counter offered MJD/Knox for Welker, and is waiting for reply now