trade for Vick or Newton?

[introspect]

thinking about trying this offer:

my: Fitzpatrick+MichaelTurner+Lloyd+D.Moore
for his: Vick+FelixJones+MikeWallce

should I ask for Newton instead of Vick? Or just keep my team as is?

8 team standard head-to-head yahoo league

QB: Romo || Fitzpatrcik
WR: Nicks, S.Smith (CAR), Bowe || Lloyd, D.Moore
RB: MJD, CJ2K || Michael Turner
TE: Gresham || Witten (Bye week)
K: Hanson
DEF: TEN || Pittsburgh (about to drop Pits for Ingram)