Who's More Valuable to trade for - Hillis, McGahee, or Addai

[tapionminoshi]

I'm looking to make a trade with an owner who has Hillis, McGahee, and Addai. He has shown interest in SGreene, Felix Jones, and Brandon Marshall from my team. I like Felix Jones by far the best of the 3 on my side, and I think I like Hillis the best from his team. What should I offer him?

thinking of offering Greene + BMarshall for Hillis. or should i be targeting mcgahee or addai instead?


Standard 10 team league, bonuses for 40+ yd rushing TDs, 100+ yd rushing days, and 300+ yd passing days.

Here's his team:

Matt Schaub, Hou QB
RB Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac RB
RB Mike Tolbert, SD RB
RB/WR Joseph Addai, Ind RB
WR Greg Jennings, GB WR
WR Larry Fitzgerald, Ari WR
TE Tony Gonzalez, Atl TE
D/ST 49ers D/ST D/ST
K David Akers, SF K

Bench Peyton Hillis, Cle RB
Bench Mike Williams, TB WR
Bench Willis McGahee, Den RB
Bench Julio Jones, Atl W
Bench Jets D/ST D/ST
Bench Denarius Moore, Oak WR
Bench Roy Helu, Wsh RB

my team :
QB Michael Vick
RB Jahvid Best
RB Shonn Greene
RB/WR Isaac Redman
WR Calvin Johnson
WR Plaxico Burress
TE Jimmy Graham
D/ST Lions D/ST
K Jason Hansen

BENCH
RB Steven Jackson
RB Felix Jones
RB Ben Tate
WR Santana Moss
WR Brandon Marshall
WR Jacoby Jones
QB Ryan Fitzpatrick

[DVauthrin]

hillis has the highest upside of the 3 players so he would be my target. you would be overpaying by a lot for addai or mcgahee.

[rclement3915]

I wouldn't give up Marshall... You'd be making yourself thinner at WR.

[MadDog36]

Greene+Marshall for his Hillis makes sense for the both of you. I do not like Shonn Greene at all. See if you can make that deal. Dolphins are a mess.

[tapionminoshi]

Hes verbally agreed to do Greene+Marshall for Hillis after this weeks games (im super thin this week due to byes).

Or should I just do it now to make sure he doesnt change his mind and run with a really weak team for the week? I'm 4-0, and my opponent this week probably has the strongest team in the league, with none of his starters on byes, while i'm missing half my team as it is.

I'm also in talks of trading Ryan Fitzpatrick for LaGarrette Blount.