Nicks for Bradshaw (plus others) - WHIR

[bstock123]

He would give me his A. Bradshaw, A. Boldin, and J. Cutler for my H. Nicks and D. Williams.

My thoughts: on face value it seems pretty good for me. However, when you look at my squad below, I don't really need the RB (except for this week) as much as I do the WR. Mendy will probably be out for me this week, but if I accepted the trade today, I don't think it'd be approved by game-time Sunday. I guess the question really boils down to do we see Mendy as a legit RB2 going forward, and is Boldin a good enough replacement for losing Nicks. I start 3 WRs. Let me know your thoughts, and, as always, WHIR.

12-Team Standard Scoring League (1pt/10rush/rec yards, 1pt/25 pass yds, 6 pt TD pass)
Redraft, No PPR
Start: 1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1K, 1DST

QB: M. Stafford
RB: R. Rice, R. Mendenhall, D. Williams, J. Starks, I. Redman
WR: H. Nicks, M. Williams (TB), J. Jones, A.J. Green
TE: A. Gates, A. Hernandez (will pick up a TE this week if necessary)

[brenglen]

He would give me his A. Bradshaw, A. Boldin, and J. Cutler for my H. Nicks and D. Williams.

My thoughts: on face value it seems pretty good for me. However, when you look at my squad below, I don't really need the RB (except for this week) as much as I do the WR. Mendy will probably be out for me this week, but if I accepted the trade today, I don't think it'd be approved by game-time Sunday. I guess the question really boils down to do we see Mendy as a legit RB2 going forward, and is Boldin a good enough replacement for losing Nicks. I start 3 WRs. Let me know your thoughts, and, as always, WHIR.

12-Team Standard Scoring League (1pt/10rush/rec yards, 1pt/25 pass yds, 6 pt TD pass)
Redraft, No PPR
Start: 1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1K, 1DST

QB: M. Stafford
RB: R. Rice, R. Mendenhall, D. Williams, J. Starks, I. Redman
WR: H. Nicks, M. Williams (TB), J. Jones, A.J. Green
TE: A. Gates, A. Hernandez (will pick up a TE this week if necessary)

Boy thats a tough trade. Both Culter and Williams are not cutting it this year so basically its Boldin and Bradshaw for Nicks. God I wish I was a fan of Eli Manning and for that I might pull the trigger on this trade, especially with Evans out and the run game the giants have.

If you dont mind helpin me out? viewtopic.php?t=502271

[MadDog36]

Pass. You need Nicks more than another RB IMO. Is Redman available?

Post FAs.

[bstock123]

I picked up Redman earlier in the week. Not much on the WW in terms of RBs. K. Hunter, E. Graham, D. Carter, R. Helu....the usual suspects in a 12-team league.

[JP555]

Yea I don't like it. Hang on to Nicks for now, too valuable to your team

any advice? viewtopic.php?t=502430

[SdxFactor]

Yeah I wouldn't do that, like stated above you really won't be imporving you're starting line-up. You need nicks he's been solid all year. Williams will porably get better as the year goes on, but Mendy is a beast slow start this year but give him time.