Romo/Wells/Maclin for Smith/Austin?

[bcbhockey68]

12 Team PPR standard scoring except 6pt for passing TDs

What are your thoughts on this trade? My Romo (or Cam), Wells and Maclin for his Steve Smith and Miles Austin? Is this fair and does it benefit both our teams?

My Team:
QB Tony Romo
RB Ray Rice
RB Darren McFadden
WR Brandon Marshall
WR Mario Manningham
TE Owen Daniels
K Billy Cundiff
Def/St Chargers
BN Jeremy Maclin
BN Brandon Lloyd
BN Cam Newton
BN Beanie Wells
BN Michael Bush
BN Rian Lindell

His Team:
J Freeman
J Cutler (R)
J Starks
W McGahee
D Thomas (R)
P Hillis (R)
G Jennings
S Smith
M Austin (R)
N Washington (R)
V Davis
M Bryant
Bengals
Jets (R)

[Pengh]

I kinda like it considering you have Cam and stud RB already. You could use those new receivers... only reason i said "kinda" is what happens if Cam/McFadden/Rice Go down. Where are your backups....


oh
viewtopic.php?t=503062

[bcbhockey68]

That is the nature of the beast if you are trying to field the best possible starting lineup. M. Bush is there if DMC goes down but if Rice or Cam goes down I might be forced to turn around and trade or pick up WW players.

[Eightan]

Definitely a good deal for you as you get monster upgrades at both WR spots. Question for me is which QB to trade, as the 6 pts for passing TD's kind of evens out Romo with Cam....

That being said, I'd probably trade Romo because a) he plays in a tougher division (NFC East vs. NFC South) and b) if you have S.Smith and Cam, it's going to be nice to get all those total points from those bomb TD'S; imagine getting like 24 or 25 total points from an 80 yard bomb- Cam to Smith.... will be sweet!

[bcbhockey68]

anyone else?

[bcbhockey68]

I sent it...we shall see what he says.

[bounce]

I like it. It gives you a stud at every position. Id rather have that than a deep bench.

Help me?

viewtopic.php?t=503319

[Curtis Pride]

Lopsided in your favor.

If it's an offer, accept it immediately (with Romo so you can hedge your weekly exposure to Dallas). If it's an offer you are considering, it's not going to be accepted.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=503327

[bcbhockey68]

well then...why don't you give me some alternatives?

[Curtis Pride]

Because I don't think the point of this forum is for everyone to create trades for you from scratch. Everyone else in the forum provides their own alternatives in a post and people reply with their preference.

To assume that people are going to study the rosters for 10 minutes and create a bunch of alternatives for you, is a bit selfish.