Steven Jackson, Turner, or Mendenhall for Wayne??

[CSimmsSU]

12 team, ppr. Start 2RB, 2WR and Flex
Im looking to add another WR as I am thin and weak at the position and have a surplus of RBs and another guy is looking for another RB.

My Team:
QB: Rodgers, A Smith
RBs: Turner, S Jackson, Mendenhall, Benson, Tate
WRs: D Jackson, M Williams TB, Crabtree, Burelson, Floyd, Ford, Sanzenbacher
TE: Pettigrew, Watson

His Team:
QB: E Manning, Hasselback, P Manning
RB: Foster, D Thomas, Stewart, Cadillac Williams
WR: Jennings, Wayne, M Thomas, Collie
TE: Witten, Gonzalez

He is not willing to deal Jennings so thats out and we've tried to work something with Witten and Wayne coming to me but nothing so far. He is looking for 1 for 1 of Wayne for either Turner, S Jackson or Mendenhall. But Im hesitant as I can roll with all 3 of those (one at flex) and just use D Jackson and either Williams or Crabtree as my WR2. Any suggestions on trade offers to get more than Wayne from him and who do you see as having best/worst season of Turner, S Jackson, and Mendenhall? Im thinking S Jackson (poor team) or Mendenhall (injuries/competition for carries) as being the lowest valued. Don't think he has an interest in Benson.

[CSimmsSU]

I was conidering S Jackson OR Mendenhall with Tate (since he has Foster) for D Thomas and Wayne? Or should I just stay put as Wayne will be up and down all year on a bad team with young QB

[latsprewell20002000]

Dude dont trade for Wayne. Its sad to say this cause Wayne was a hell of a player, but without Manning hes nothing. Hes getting out played by Garcon and he looks slow. I would target someone else if I was you.

[MadDog36]

Tate for Wayne makes sense for you both.