I am a Cowboys homer. I think Dez is a beast if he stays on the field. He can go up and get the ball in almost any situation and has proven it this year so far.
That being said, Dez has the potential to go off and be top 5 the rst of the year, IF he stays on the field. We all know he has the talent and ability to be top 5, he just needs the playing time, without injury.
Maclin is a little safer because he can stay on the field. He quarterback isnt as good a passer as Romo, and has been battling his own injuries. Dez has the ability to out produce Maclin, but Maclin you pretty much know will be on the field.
So its pick between Rick vs Reward. You can get more reward with Dez, but also more Risk.
I wouldnt do it, just because I am a Cowboys fan, and I like Dez.