To me, this is a tougher decision than it seems...
Thomas will be back in action against a defense that has been, well, suspect as of late. Their run defense showed no vital signs against a mediocre running back last week (The Law Firm). Thomas will most likely get about 20 touches in the game, which based on his averages, goes for about 80yds, and a potential TD. He is coming back from the ever-dreadful hamstring injury, and that scares me a bit.
Garcon on the other hand, has been riding a nice streak. Now, two weeks ago, he only had two catches. Granted, they both went for TD's, but he has been the beneficiary of busted coverage. I'm not saying he is not a gifted athlete, but shame on you if you don' catch the ball (and score) when there is no defender within 15 yards of you. I do also know he made some great catches this past week against KC, but the thing that worries me the most is Cincy's D. They are NO pushover. If I'm not mistaken, they rank inside the top 5 for both pass D and run D.
I honestly think you go Thomas here. I may be wrong, but that is what my gut is telling me.
Help me out pls,viewtopic.php?t=503541