Help me make a trade WHIR

[jetzman51]

I have 2 Tes and 2 Wrs who have a bye week next week so im trying to trade Vernon Davis this week while he has high stock and I have Hernandez as a back up. The dude who wants him has a so so roster and im not sure who to trade for. I like Daniel Thomas but i think Davis for Thomas is to much. not sure what to try for

His Roster My Roster
QB Tom Brady Matt Stafford
Rb Jahvid Best Jones-Drew
Green-Ellis Steven Jackson
Daniel Thomas Felix Jones
WR Santonio Holmes Hakeem Nicks
Brandon Marshall Jeremy Maclin
TE Jermain Gresham Vernon Davis

Bench Cutler, Nate Washington Tebow, Jackie Battle, Heyward Bey, Aaron hernandez, Andre Johnson
Mike Thomas Fred davis Steven Ridley

[ceche004]

tough trade, if you have depth at TE I would personally take a daniel thomas. I might wait till next week though to see how he does against the jets. Not sure if i trust the hammy.

[schmidty]

It would help to see the other guy's bench. And I don't know about others, but your "His roster My roster" layout is hard on my eyes to take in - just listing out the teams one after the other is easier for me to follow.

It depends on the other guy's bench options at RB and WR. BJGE seems banged up at the moment - at might be a tough sell to get Thomas at the moment. If it was my team, I certainly wouldn't want to do it just to upgrade Gresham to VDavis. Maybe try to buy low on Marshall (who gets his bye out of the way this week) with VDavis plus one of your WRs (not Nicks or AJ obviously)?

[latsprewell20002000]

It would help to see the other guy's bench. And I don't know about others, but your "His roster My roster" layout is hard on my eyes to take in - just listing out the teams one after the other is easier for me to follow.

It depends on the other guy's bench options at RB and WR. BJGE seems banged up at the moment - at might be a tough sell to get Thomas at the moment. If it was my team, I certainly wouldn't want to do it just to upgrade Gresham to VDavis. Maybe try to buy low on Marshall (who gets his bye out of the way this week) with VDavis plus one of your WRs (not Nicks or AJ obviously)?

Yeah but I doubt he really wants Marshall now with the QB change. I know I wouldnt...

[schmidty]

It would help to see the other guy's bench. And I don't know about others, but your "His roster My roster" layout is hard on my eyes to take in - just listing out the teams one after the other is easier for me to follow.

It depends on the other guy's bench options at RB and WR. BJGE seems banged up at the moment - at might be a tough sell to get Thomas at the moment. If it was my team, I certainly wouldn't want to do it just to upgrade Gresham to VDavis. Maybe try to buy low on Marshall (who gets his bye out of the way this week) with VDavis plus one of your WRs (not Nicks or AJ obviously)?

Yeah but I doubt he really wants Marshall now with the QB change. I know I wouldnt...

I keep hearing that. But it's not like his QB was someone like Peyton, Brady, or Brees ... it was Henne. I think that big physical WRs like Marshall tend to "get theirs" regardless of QB play - at least to a much greater extent than smaller speedy WRs like SSmith or DJax (who need a QB that can chuck it down the field). If the cost was VDavis (plus a bench WR), I'd want the Marshall side (if I already had Hernandez).

[latsprewell20002000]

It would help to see the other guy's bench. And I don't know about others, but your "His roster My roster" layout is hard on my eyes to take in - just listing out the teams one after the other is easier for me to follow.

It depends on the other guy's bench options at RB and WR. BJGE seems banged up at the moment - at might be a tough sell to get Thomas at the moment. If it was my team, I certainly wouldn't want to do it just to upgrade Gresham to VDavis. Maybe try to buy low on Marshall (who gets his bye out of the way this week) with VDavis plus one of your WRs (not Nicks or AJ obviously)?

Yeah but I doubt he really wants Marshall now with the QB change. I know I wouldnt...

I keep hearing that. But it's not like his QB was someone like Peyton, Brady, or Brees ... it was Henne. I think that big physical WRs like Marshall tend to "get theirs" regardless of QB play - at least to a much greater extent than smaller speedy WRs like SSmith or DJax (who need a QB that can chuck it down the field). If the cost was VDavis (plus a bench WR), I'd want the Marshall side (if I already had Hernandez).

Yeah and that proves my point even more. He was HENNE'S backup. As in not as good as Henne.....

[jetzman51]

sorry i had the rosters spaced out but it got rid of the spaces when i posted it i guess. Thanks for the help