Vick or Cam ??

[captkirkcud]

Been tossing this one back and forth all week long....I am leaning towards Vick seeing that this is a must win for the Eagles. Also, should i start Gore vs. Det....or Benson vs. Indy?
10 Team league, team is 5-0 so far.

QB – Michael Vick / Cam Newton
WR – Wes Welker
WR – Mike Wallace
WR – Steve Smith (Car)
RB – Michael Turner
RB – Frank Gore
TE – Jimmy Graham
K – John Kasey
D – Cincy

B - Antonio Gates
B - Cedric Benson
B - Anquan Boldin
B - James Starks
B - Jackie Battle

[captkirkcud]

anyone???

[cloudng8]

Honestly If i had cam i would prob start them... this isn't the redskins of last year and vick isnt going to go off like that again... There D is a lot better i have vick too and im praying that he doesn't throw 4 interceptions like he did last game but if i had cam i would def start him over vick for this week.

[captkirkcud]

This looks like it's going to be a gametime decision for me...either way i like both of there chances.

[doomedn00b]

The upside to Cam is just too great, you gotta start him. As far as your back, I'd start Benson. Indy is shaky at best this season, and for the past few years, the best way to beat the Colts is to run the ball, over and over and over. Cam and Benson fo sho.

[Dolfin99]

I would go with Cam and Gore.

I have them ranked as follows:

Cam - 3
Vick - 7

[cooker]

You shouldn't even be having this debate. Why have a #1 QB as a backup? Upgrade your team at WR/RB per the best deal you can get. Look for the guy in your league that is hurting at QB or the guy that is overstacked at one of your need positions. Foolish to have these two on one team if you can't use them weekly. Flip a coin this week but make a trade next week before next. It might be nice to see them both on your roster but it's not helping your team at all.

[SolvusAnima]

Start Cam and Benson this week, upside for Cam cannot be ignored. Also, Indy defense is pretty bad, so Benson should have a solid, solid game.

Help with mine is appreciated: viewtopic.php?t=503643

[Dublin1]

Go with Cam and trade Vick.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=504022

[Chowdaheads]

You shouldn't even be having this debate. Why have a #1 QB as a backup? Upgrade your team at WR/RB per the best deal you can get. Look for the guy in your league that is hurting at QB or the guy that is overstacked at one of your need positions. Foolish to have these two on one team if you can't use them weekly. Flip a coin this week but make a trade next week before next. It might be nice to see them both on your roster but it's not helping your team at all.

I'm in the same boat, and have been trying to deal either one for weeks. It ain't as simple as saying "trade with me", especially considering the injury risk of Vick, and the fact that Cam is a rookie.

I have Cam in this week, and multiple trade offers out to deal Vick... keeping my fingers crossed!