I play in an 8 team league that my wife asked me to play in. You have to start 3 WR (no flex) and she has Welker, Wallace, AJ Green, and Andre Johnson. You start 1 TE, and her tight ends are Dustin Keller and Dallas Clark.
I have WR's Roddy White, Julio Jones, Mike WIlliams (TB), and Brandon Marshall. My tight ends are Jimmy Graham and Jermichael Finley.
I offered her Jimmy Graham for Andre Johnson which to me seemed like a fair trade but the commissioner called us out saying it was skeptical and looked like collusion between husband and wife.
At first he said why would anyone trade for an injured player, but then he went on to say a TE is never worth a top WR. I assume he thinks the team getting Graham got ripped off somehow. In our scoring format, only 5 WRs have more points than Graham and Graham is the top scoring TE. He also said Graham is overrated because of who is throwing to him (Brees). I have no clue what that means in terms of fantasy football. Yeah Graham gets more points because his QB is Brees, he certainly isnt an overrated fantasy TE.
Am I missing something in this trade or is this commissioner just being a crybaby? I certainly didnt like being called out for collusion when I feel both teams benefit from the trade.