Roddy White/Mark Ingram for Calvin Johnson - WHIR!

[curly]

0.5ppr league

I am being offered Roddy White and Mark Ingram for my Calvin Johnson.

This is my roster:
QB - Freeman, Tebow
RB - Gore, Tomlinson, Carter, Redman
WR - Calvin Johnson, Austin, Moss, Holmes
TE - Keller, Watson

The other manager involved in the trade does not want to give up his lead back McCoy because his only other back is Blount.

Should I make this trade?
Or should I counter by giving him Miles Austin and one of my lesser backs or just Miles Austin?

Also, note that he or no one else in the league wants Moss or Holmes, so I am stuck with them.

I am currently sitting 2-4 after this week and as you can see, I am weak at RB.

[Therobsclub]

No way!!! If you're giving up Calvin you better be getting McCoy! Offer him Calvin and a lesser back for McCoy and White.

Help?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=504261

[curly]

He doesn't want to part with him. Should I counter with Austin/Tomlinson for White/Ingram?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SF2313]

Hmmmm very tricky trade. I'd take the trade if Ingram is replaced with Blount or if you offer Miles and get Roddy and Ingram.

[rclement3915]

I'd Easily pass.


Help me out:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=504276

[curly]

Austin for White/Ingram?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ian]

White has been crap this year and if Austin comes back fully healthy, he should end up with a better year. Plus, Bryant is going to take some coverage away from him when he is back.

I'd pass on it.

[SacKings384]

Absolutely not... Calvin is the best WR in football and Julio Jones is getting more targets than Roddy!

www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/view ... p?t=504316