WHIR blockbuster trade help

[bradleyk]

I need an answer kinda soon if I can.

Calvin Johnson, Ray Rice, and Dallas Clark for Cam Newton, Payton Hillis, Steve Smith, Mario Manningham, and Benjamin Watson.

It's a PPR league.

Here's my roster
q- Josh Freeman
r - Ray Rice
r/w - Shonn Green
wr - Calvin Johnson
wr - Eric Decker
te - Brandon Pettigrew
d - steelers
k - Ryan Lindal
coach - bill's coach

bench
W Nate Washington
W Jason Avant
TE Dallas Clark
QB - Alex Smith
QB - (soon to be dropped) Rex Grossman
D Redskins
RB Jonathan Stewart
RB Ryan Torrain

[prophecy135]

I dont like this deal for you. You'd be giving up the two best, and possibly the two best players in the league, for Cam? I dont see alot in that deal other then Cam and S. Smith for you. I dont really like it at all, just getting a bunch of okay guys for you're 2 great and 1 soso guy isnt that good of a deal IMO.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=504320

[bradleyk]

alright. I was starting to have some reservations about it, which is why I came here. Thanks.

[schmidty]

With Hillis' hamstring issues, I think you want to stay away from that boat. And I wouldn't be a fan if he was healthy ... he's still sucking and has an awful playoff schedule. And the above poster is right ... giving away the 2 best players in a deal usually isn't a successful way to trade.

[futanto]

Dont do this trade, unless you swap out one of those for an A++ player I would not do it. You have the two best players.

[bradleyk]

Thanks, everyone. I don't do it then.