Not very scientific here but I say go with McGahee. Reason: There is one undefeated team in our 12 team league. He is starting McGahee. Regardless of who he starts they have a solid week and usually a great week. We all think he could start someone on a bye and they would find a way to get 10 points. This guy's picks have been fantasy gold.
If you want a real reason to support McGahee, how about this. Starks will split carries with Grant. Less chance of that happening with McGahee, right?
Please take a look at mineviewtopic.php?t=505168