Megatronic trade

[OldManRiver]

14 team league - 1QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 FLEX, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF - Standard Yahoo Scoring NO-PPR

Me
QB - Freeman (A. Smith)
WR - Megatron, P Harvin
RB - MJD, L Blount, M Lynch (DWill, P Thomas, E Graham)
TE - D Keller (J Greshem)
K - R Gould
DEf - CHi

Him
QB - Roethlisberger (Hasselbeck)
WR - Roddy White, Colston, A Boldin (L Moore, K Walter, M Clayton)
RB - Mendenhall, Tolbert ( Ringer, Moreno)
TE - J Graham
K - Bailey
DEf - NYJ


I intially offered DWill and Lynch for Mendy because he is so thin at RB. He countered with Megatron, DWill, Lynch for Roddy, Mendy, L Moore. What do you guys think.

[latsprewell20002000]

Dont like it. You lose Megatron and only get back a struggling Roddy and Mendy? Pass!!

[ECG77]

No way!

You lose the best WR in the game this season. Roddy White can be a stud also but hasn't been exactly playing well. And Moore really? He knows Moore has no value with Colston back and a hot TE in Graham who he both owns.

You don't have any other WRs in your line up?

Lend a hand.
viewtopic.php?t=505144

[plapre3]

Yuk. Please do not do this. If I'm giving up Megatron, I want at least one stud in return and other very useful parts. Roddy White could and should be a stud, but right now he simply isn't. I like White as a buy low, but trading the most dominant player in the game away to get him certainly isn't a buy low.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=505120

[OldManRiver]

Yeah i really wanted to try and counter but i really dont see anything guess ill just have to pass. Ty for your help guys.

[MadDog36]

See selling high and buying low is a good idea, but not when the situation doesn't look like its going to improve much.

viewtopic.php?t=505124