Trade Garcon & Harvin for Battle & D.Nelson?

[danvan18]

already have AP, Gore, Lynch, Addai at RB, but I have Wallace, S.Smith, Colston, Garcon, Moss, Harvin at WR. I like the swap of Garcon for Battle, but is Harvin for David Nelson even enough to warrant doing?

Battle has serious potential to be a nice back the rest of the way...

WHIR

[jasondhoffmann]

No. Garcon is one of the top WRs in the league. Battle is unproven with some nice upside. I ould not just give up Garcon. I have him, and being on the colts scares me, and that QB scares me, but, but -- he has been very very productive and I think thats with 2 wks off. Battle who? A possiblity. A maybe. See how he does , becasue even if Battle tears it up this week the trade should still be on the ta=ble. It is just 1 week. But you do run the risk of the other owner pulling it because then he will feel like battle is hot.

I wouldnt just yet, and maybe not ever...Garcon is this years Astin I think

mine:

viewtopic.php?t=505233

thx

[MadDog36]

Wow. Tough one. You have enough RB so I'd keep your only productive WR/3 type.