Beanie/Sidney for Murray/Harvin WHIR

[bdk140]

12 team 2 qb PPR
qb 3 WR 2 RB TE Q/R/W/T
My team
Qb Brees, Stafford, Alex smith, Shaun hill
Wr Nicks Decker A. Brown Rice
RB McCoy, Wells, Felix Jones, Jackie Battle, Ronnie Brown, Chris Obysomething CLE
te olson clark
Thinking of proposing this trade not sure how it looks wanna see what you think just leave a link

[MMhawk607]

I would definitely see about Beanie's injuries. If they're anything serious or looks like he'll be seeing limited touches then maybe.

But as of now, I think Beanie's too valuable to trade to get Murray. Reason being.. I know Murray had that great game today, but there's no saying that he'll be that great against a better rushing defense. and once Jones comes in, he's Number 1 in the RB spot so he'll probably get most of the touches. Cowboys really like to pass it a lot so Murray's chances aren't really looking good.

I like the Sidney for Harvin part but if you have to trade away Beanie and only get Murray for it, I wouldn't do it. IMO.

advice?:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=505419

[ATLbraves]

If DeMarco continues to play well going forward I dont think they are going to be able to just give Felix the starting role back.

[Captain Crunch]

Agree. My hunch is has already been made clear that Murray is the new #1 RB. Look at Jones's career numbers - nothing close to this game and he has started against a number of poor defenses over the last few years. I might even argue he has underachieved so far in his career. Jerry likes buzz, and Murray has a lot of buzz right now.